⚔️ Head-to-Head Overlap Analysis

XLE vs VDE Overlap & Concentration Screener

Comparing Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund and Vanguard Energy ETF. Uncover shared underlying stock holdings, sector concentration, and whether holding these funds creates redundant portfolio drag.

⚖️ Select Your ETF Allocation (Up to 6)

Add ETFs and set your target weights. Real-time look-through calculates your true single-stock and sector exposure.

Allocation Total:
100%
Executive Summary (Equal Allocation)

Analyzing Portfolio Allocation...

Calculating --%

Analyzing look-through constituent overlap, fee drag, and single-stock concentration...

Top 5 Concentration --%
Top 10 Concentration --%
Unique Holdings --
Blended Fee --%
Largest Shared Holdings

🔄 Pairwise ETF Overlap & Redundancy Analysis

Calculating...

High overlap between two funds means you are paying multiple expense ratios for virtually the same underlying companies.

🔍 True Underlying Stock Exposure (Look-Through)

Your real aggregate ownership in single stocks after multiplying your ETF allocations by each fund's holdings.

Concentration Heatmap (Top Holdings)
High (>6%) Moderate (3%–6%) Diversified (<3%)
Detailed Holdings Breakdown
Stock / Company Effective Weight Contributing ETFs

📊 Sector Exposures vs Broad Market Benchmark (VTI)

Shows where your ETF combination is heavily overweight (concentrated tilt) or underweight compared to the total US stock market.

Save & Share This Portfolio Analysis

Bookmark this URL or share with friends to load these exact ETFs and weights.

📥 Free Printable PDF Guide One-Page Reference • Instant PDF

Download Ideal Low-Overlap ETF Pairings & Model Portfolios (PDF)

Eliminate redundant holding drag and tech concentration. Get 5 benchmark portfolio allocations with Venn diagrams and constituent overlap scores.

  • ✓ Visual Venn diagrams comparing popular pairs (VOO vs VTI, QQQ vs VOO)
  • ✓ 5 proven model allocations (Reddit Trio, Bogleheads 3-Fund, Factor Barbell)
  • ✓ Exact step-by-step rebalancing guidelines and look-through weight rules

✉ Includes the free Buck by Buck personal finance newsletter. Instant download unlocked immediately. Unsubscribe anytime with 1 click.

Other Popular ETF Overlap Comparisons

View all comparisons
ETF Comparison 90% overlap

VOO vs VTI Overlap & Concentration Risk Analyzer

Compare overlapping holdings between VOO, VTI. See true underlying stock exposure, sector concentration, and expense drag without redundant fees.

View breakdown
ETF Comparison 53% overlap

VOO vs QQQ Overlap & Concentration Risk Analyzer

Compare overlapping holdings between VOO, QQQ. See true underlying stock exposure, sector concentration, and expense drag without redundant fees.

View breakdown
ETF Comparison 47% overlap

VTI vs QQQ Overlap & Concentration Risk Analyzer

Compare overlapping holdings between VTI, QQQ. See true underlying stock exposure, sector concentration, and expense drag without redundant fees.

View breakdown
❓ Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions: XLE vs VDE

Answers on overlap redundancy, top holding duplication, and allocation tradeoffs between XLE and VDE.

How much do XLE and VDE overlap?

At equal allocations, XLE and VDE exhibit an overall overlap and redundancy score of 100%. Your asset allocation exhibits significant single-stock reliance or severe duplication across your chosen funds.

What are the top overlapping stock holdings between XLE and VDE?

The largest shared stock holdings across XLE and VDE include Exxon Mobil Corporation (22.8%), Chevron Corporation (15.4%), ConocoPhillips (8.8%), EOG Resources Inc. (4.8%), Schlumberger N.V. (4.6%), Marathon Petroleum Corporation (4.4%), Phillips 66 (3.8%), Valero Energy Corporation (3.6%).

What is the combined top 5 stock concentration when holding XLE and VDE?

Holding equal weights in XLE and VDE results in 56.4% of your total capital concentrated in just 5 individual companies.

Your Next Step & Related Guides

View all resources
💬 Reader Discussion & Notes

Discussion 🟢 Open for Discussion

Between these funds, which allocation fits your portfolio plan best?

⚡ The author reads every submission and typically replies within 24 hours.